A Complete Unknown: Bob Dylan and The “Misunderstood Artiste”

James Mangold’s A Complete Unknown is an ambitious biographical portrait of Bob Dylan, capturing the enigmatic artist’s rise to fame between 1961 and the infamous Newport Folk Festival incident of 1965. Timothée Chalamet embodies Dylan with a beguiling intensity, delivering a performance that is equal parts distant and magnetic. Surrounding him is a stellar ensemble that enriches Dylan’s mystique: Edward Norton as folk singer Pete Seeger, Elle Fanning as artist and girlfriend Sylvie Russo, Monica Barbaro as singer-songwriter Joan Baez, and Dan Fogler as music manager Albert Grossman. Together, they help craft not just a story of one man’s ascension but a layered examination of musical genius.

Much of A Complete Unknown is devoted to unraveling Dylan’s contradictions, and the supporting cast plays a critical role in building this kaleidoscopic image of the artist. Sylvie Russo (Fanning) and Joan Baez (Barbaro) challenge Dylan’s often callous dishonesty, calling out his fabrications and leaving the audience to wonder: how much of Dylan’s persona is real? While both characters are seen in ideological opposition to Dylan, they are developed beyond their roles as foils. Sylvie seems to represent the disillusionment of a generation torn between idolization and skepticism, grappling with her ambitions as she confronts Dylan’s shifting identity. Meanwhile, Baez offers a poignant counterpoint to Dylan’s evasiveness, navigating her artistic integrity while facing the emotional fallout of their turbulent relationship. The film embraces this ambiguity, refusing to offer neat answers about the man behind the music. But this isn’t new ground for musical biopics. A Complete Unknown invites comparisons to Bohemian Rhapsody and Walk the Line, asking: do we need to relate to someone like Dylan to appreciate his genius? Or is his elusiveness precisely the point?  

Mangold’s direction shines in the way it examines Dylan’s eccentricity not as a quirk but as a reflection of the artistic process and the music industry’s demands. The film skips Dylan’s early years, instead diving straight into his arrival in Greenwich Village, where he encounters folk legends Woody Guthrie (Scoot McNairy) and Pete Seeger (Norton). The gritty streets of New York are brought to life through decent cinematography by Phedon Papamichael which contrasts intimate interiors with somewhat atmospheric shots of the city. But it is important to see the setting as a character in itself than a historical backdrop. By mirroring the tension between artistic purity (e.g., the Newport Folk Festival) and the commercial pressures (e.g., New York City itself) that haunt Dylan’s journey, we see a nuanced side to the singer's tale. These moments anchor the film, grounding Dylan’s mythos in a vibrant community of artists and visionaries. 

Chalamet’s Dylan isn’t particularly concerned with being liked, and his interactions with his peers are laced with a quiet arrogance that borders on cruelty. Yet, through Mangold’s lens, this behavior feels less like ego and more like survival—an artist carving out a space in an industry that commodifies authenticity even as it destroys it. The music and singing play a crucial role in building the legend, with Chalamet delivering raw (and quite impressive) renditions of Dylan’s early songs. Similar to all music biopics, the performances replicate the sound but focus on capturing the emotional core of Dylan’s transformative lyrics. While the music serves as a personal expression (and a tool for self-definition), the use of folk standards and original songs creates an immersive lyrical landscape, reflecting the tension in Dylan’s evolution from a promising young talent to an artist forced to reckon with his own contradictions. 

At its core, A Complete Unknown examines the price of fame, showing how Dylan’s ascent comes at the expense of those closest to him. As Dylan becomes a cultural icon, his relationships fray—particularly with Baez, whose partnership with Dylan is portrayed with a bittersweet tenderness by Barbaro. The film captures the tension between Dylan’s need for connection and his pursuit of reinvention, a duality that defines much of his career. By the time the Newport Folk Festival arrives, where Dylan controversially “goes electric,” the film has built toward a moment that feels both inevitable and shattering. It’s not just the audience that is forced to reconcile Dylan’s transformation but the man himself, caught between the weight of his legacy and the desire to break free from it. A Complete Unknown isn’t just a biopic—it’s a meditation on artistry, identity, and the inevitable sacrifices of chasing immortality.

If you enjoyed this article, please consider becoming a patron of Hyperreal Film Journal for as low as $3 a month!